~EST. FLORIDA~WORKERS’ COMPENSATION REPRESENTATION~
← Back to Blog

JCC Finds Ankle Injury Compensable but Denies Disability and Further Care

Leave a Comment / Workers Comp / Yuli Kotler / Posted November 19, 2026 at 5:02 AM EST

In Yessenia Gutierrez v. Legacy MHC Management IV/ESIS WC Claims, OJCC Case No. 26-010647NAC, Judge Natalie A. Cavallaro entered a Final Compensation Order on November 18, 2026, finding a right ankle injury compensable but denying the requested temporary disability and further medical benefits.

The community manager testified that she tripped over hoses while retrieving a golf cart to inspect properties. The judge credited her account and photographs showing an immediate bone protrusion. The order applied the narrow exception permitting proof of causation without medical testimony where the connection between accident and injury is clear.

Although the employer/carrier’s defenses had been stricken for failures to participate in the proceedings, the claimant retained the burden to prove entitlement to each benefit with admissible evidence. The judge excluded an unauthenticated form from The Orthopedic Institute, finding that the claimant had not established the requirements for treatment under the self-help provision, including medical necessity.

Without admissible medical evidence of work restrictions and their causal connection to the accident, the judge denied TPD and TTD. The judge also denied authorization of a physician and gait training for lack of medical evidence connecting the requested care to the injury and establishing medical necessity. The average weekly wage claim was denied without a substantive wage determination because disability entitlement had not been established. Jurisdiction over attorney fees and costs was reserved.

Source: Compensation Order