~EST. FLORIDA~WORKERS’ COMPENSATION REPRESENTATION~
← Back to Blog

JCC Awards TTD Without Deducting Prior TPD Payments

Leave a Comment / Workers Comp / Yuli Kotler / Posted November 21, 2026

In Kerline N. Richardson v. Cristal Palace Resort PC, LLC/Ascendant Claims Services, OJCC Case No. 16-025274NPP, Judge Neal P. Pitts entered a November 20, 2026 Final Compensation Order awarding temporary total disability (TTD) benefits from September 2 through November 9, 2026, with penalties and interest.

The employer/carrier argued that earnings reports had not been returned and that combined temporary benefits were capped at 260 weeks. The judge found both defenses waived because they were omitted from the pretrial stipulation, with no amendment or good cause offered. Alternatively, the judge found the carrier received the completed earnings reports.

The judge calculated 187.14 weeks of TTD and 74.87 weeks of temporary partial disability (TPD) payments. Applying his interpretation of the statutory revival following Westphal and the reasoning of an earlier JCC order, he concluded that prior TPD payments did not reduce the claimant's 260 weeks of available TTD. This is the reasoning of this individual compensation order; the summary does not establish a statewide appellate rule on separate benefit limits.

The judge also found insufficient evidence of medical necessity for a primary care physician who specialized in hips. An orthopedic surgeon was already authorized, and the recommended referral for a hip arthroscopy specialist was not a claim presented for determination. The order illustrates the importance of preserving defenses in the pretrial stipulation and documenting benefit payments and earnings reports.

Source: Compensation Order